
THE WIRE / FINANCIAL
Paraguay's central bank chief says the Ueno Bank collapse could cost about $1 billion in a worst case
Insured savers have largely been repaid from a deposit guarantee fund, but holders of Ueno's bonds are not covered, and the final bill depends on what the bank's assets fetch over the next one to two months.
What happened
Ueno Bank, one of Paraguay's largest banks, was placed into a resolution procedure by the Central Bank of Paraguay (BCP) on Nov. 3 for insolvency, ABC reported. The move froze the funds of about 2.94 million customers, about 1.8 million of them with active accounts, along with about $800 million in public money, including five pension funds, according to ABC.
On Wednesday, Nov. 18, the new BCP president, Jorge Luis Schreiner, gave two accounts of the damage. At a press conference reported by ABC, he said: "Today we will have between $1 billion and $1.5 billion of deficit." In an interview with AFP the same day, he said that, assuming assets now valued at zero are truly worthless, unrecoverable losses "could reach $1 billion or a little more," while cautioning that it will take at least one or two months to establish the market value of each asset.
Schreiner told AFP the deposit guarantee fund, built up over two decades to more than $1.6 billion, used about $700 million to repay depositors up to 40 minimum wages, about $18,000 each. ABC, citing the same press conference, put the amount already paid at $644 million and the cap at a little over $19,600. Schreiner said the BCP moved the accounts of about 1,812,000 people in under five days and promised that Ueno's loan and card portfolios would be fully transferred by December.
BCP board member Pedro Acosta said verified assets come to about 9 trillion guaraníes (about $1.49 billion) on a preliminary basis, and will be sold in lots to other banks to compensate larger depositors, ABC reported.
Background and history
Schreiner told AFP the collapse came from loans Ueno made above the legal limit to companies in its own business group and with ties to people in political office. "It was not a financial crisis, but the crisis of a bank," he said. G1 reported that he described rule changes that favored "a model of friends, of connections."
The failure set off a political crisis. Former President Santiago Peña was removed in a Senate impeachment trial and is in pretrial detention, and the former central bank leadership resigned and was later arrested, according to ABC and G1. G1 reported that the former central bank chief was accused of breach of trust and criminal association. Pedro Alliana is now president, AFP reported.
The guarantee fund covers bank deposits only. About $350 million in international bonds issued by Ueno, plus other local debt, falls outside it, Schreiner said, according to ABC.
Our analysis
This is a large shock for Paraguay: a bank failure that drained a big share of a fund that took two decades to build and brought down a sitting president. The figures are sourced to the central bank chief himself and carried by AFP, France 24, G1 and ABC, though the range he gave (about $1 billion to AFP, $1 billion to $1.5 billion at the press conference) shows how uncertain the final number still is.
The main open risk is legal. Schreiner warned that foreign bondholders could sue "not only the bank, but the State," because the information given to them about Ueno was not accurate, and said Paraguay should be prepared for an international claim, ABC reported.
Outside Paraguay the effect looks limited so far; Schreiner himself framed it as one bank's failure, not a system-wide crisis. Our scanner ranked it 7. We think that reflects the size of the loss and its political fallout, but for a U.S. reader a somewhat lower rank would also be fair.
What to watch next
No action is needed in the United States.
Signposts: the market valuation of Ueno's assets over the next one to two months, which will set the real loss; the transfer of the loan and card portfolios, promised by December; the first International Monetary Fund technical mission, which Schreiner said is expected in December to review central bank laws and operations; and any lawsuit by holders of Ueno's foreign bonds.
Confidence and rank
Our confidence is high. Figures come from the central bank chief's interview with AFP, repeated by France 24 and G1; other local estimates put the deficit as high as $1.5 billion.
Our read of the risk to a general reader is medium — The damage is large for Paraguay but limited outside the country so far.
How we rank
Ranks run from 0 to 10 and follow published scoring rules, including how widely a story reaches and how many independent sources report it. A high rank is not the same as a high risk to you. How we score →
More on The Wire