
THE WIRE / POLITICAL
Egyptian editor Lina Attalah's retrial is expected to be put off again while an appeals court decides on Nov. 26 whether to replace the judge
The editor of Mada Masr faces a retrial over a one-year prison sentence she says she never knew about. The judge hearing it is the one who fined her and ordered her outlet closed last month.
What happened
On Tuesday, Oct. 27, the New Cairo Misdemeanour Court convicted Lina Attalah, co-founder and editor-in-chief of the independent news site Mada Masr, of running a website without a licence. It fined her 3 million Egyptian pounds, about $56,000, ordered Mada Masr closed and its equipment confiscated, Reuters and the BBC reported. Attalah was briefly detained and released after Mada Masr paid the fine, the Guardian reported. Her lawyers said the court rejected their requests to review the case file and submit evidence and appointed a lawyer for her against her objections; Egypt's Supreme Judicial Council later rejected suggestions the trial was unfair, Reuters reported.
While completing her release, her lawyers discovered that a court had sentenced her in absentia in 2024 to one year in prison for publishing false news and operating a website without a licence. The Egyptian Initiative for Personal Rights (EIPR) says neither she nor the Journalists Syndicate was told of the referral to trial or the verdict for more than two years.
The retrial opened on Wednesday, Nov. 11, before the same judge, Mohamed Mubarak. Her defence asked him to step aside, arguing he had already formed a view against her, and he adjourned the case to Nov. 18, the BBC and Reuters reported.
On Tuesday, Nov. 17, Mada Masr lawyer Hassan El-Azhary told Al Manassa that the recusal request will be heard on Nov. 26 by the 12th Civil Circuit of the Abbassia Court of Appeal, and that the judge cannot proceed with the retrial until it is decided, so the Nov. 18 session was expected to be adjourned. Attalah's appeal against the Oct. 27 closure ruling is scheduled for Nov. 25. The outcome of the Nov. 18 session had not been reported when this was written.
Background and history
Mada Masr was set up 13 years ago and became Egypt's leading independent news site, the BBC reports, covering alleged corruption, rights abuses, politics and the economy, and wars in Libya, Sudan and Gaza; since 2017 it could only be viewed from outside Egypt. Mada Masr says it applied for a licence under a 2018 media law that introduced the requirement but received no formal decision, Reuters reported.
The 2024 case began in February that year, when prosecutors questioned Attalah over Mada Masr's coverage, accused her of the same two offences and released her on 5,000 Egyptian pounds bail, EIPR says. Al Manassa reports that, after the Oct. 27 ruling, the Supreme Judicial Council said Attalah had waived her right to appeal in writing; her defence says she never did.
The case comes amid a wider crackdown. The six-person team of the fact-checking platform Matsadaash was arrested and charged with belonging to the outlawed Muslim Brotherhood, the Guardian reported. On Nov. 10 the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights urged Egypt to halt what it described as an alarming escalation in attacks on press freedom and to end the proceedings against Attalah, Al Manassa reported.
Our analysis
The legal path now runs through two dates: the Nov. 25 appeal against the closure and fine, and the Nov. 26 ruling on whether Judge Mubarak stays on the retrial. Under Egyptian procedure as described by Al Manassa, the appeals court can reject the request, fine the applicant and send the case back to the same judge, or remove him and move the case to another circuit. The one-year sentence remains the most serious risk to Attalah personally.
Rights groups and the UN frame the case as a measure of whether any independent newsroom can operate in Egypt. Attalah told the BBC the crackdown was meant to "send a chilling message" to the few newsrooms left.
Our scanner ranked this a 6. It is a well-sourced, widely covered press-freedom story, but it poses no direct risk to readers in the United States, so we rate its risk as low.
What to watch next
No action is needed.
Signposts: confirmation of what happened at the Nov. 18 session; the Nov. 25 appeal hearing on the closure and fine; and the Nov. 26 decision on the recusal request. If the judge is replaced, the retrial would move to another circuit. Further arrests or prosecutions of journalists in Egypt would signal the crackdown widening.
Confidence and rank
Our confidence is high. Court dates and charges come from Attalah's lawyers via Al Manassa, the BBC, Reuters and EIPR; the outcome of the Nov. 18 session had not been reported when this was written.
Our read of the risk to a general reader is low — A press-freedom and human-rights case in Egypt with no direct risk to U.S. readers.
How we rank
Ranks run from 0 to 10 and follow published scoring rules, including how widely a story reaches and how many independent sources report it. A high rank is not the same as a high risk to you. How we score →
More on The Wire