
THE WIRE / POLITICAL
South Korea's Supreme Court sends ex-Prime Minister Han Duck-soo's martial law case back to the appeals court
The justices threw out part of his 15-year sentence, finding too little proof of his intent before Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law, but upheld the findings on what he did afterward.
What happened
On Thursday, Nov. 19, South Korea's Supreme Court, sitting en banc, overturned part of the appellate ruling that had sentenced former Prime Minister Han Duck-soo to 15 years in prison for his role in the Dec. 3, 2024, martial law declaration, and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court, the Korea Herald and Hankyoreh reported. AP reported the ruling was 9-3.
The court found insufficient evidence that Han intended to subvert the constitutional order when he proposed a Cabinet meeting before former President Yoon Suk Yeol declared martial law. The majority said there was not enough evidence that Han knew the specifics of plans to deploy troops and block access to key institutions when he proposed the meeting and helped convene its members, according to the Korea Herald.
The court left the rest standing. It agreed that Yoon's declaration and the actions that followed were an insurrection, and that Han's conduct after the declaration amounted to taking part in it. It upheld findings that Han helped falsify an official document by signing a cover sheet for the martial law proclamation after martial law had been lifted, that he violated the Presidential Records Act by asking former presidential aide Kang Ui-goo to destroy that cover sheet, and that he committed perjury when he told Yoon's impeachment trial he did not recall seeing a martial law document. His acquittal on a separate charge of using a falsified document also stands, the Korea Herald reported.
Because Han's detention was due to expire on Friday, the court extended it by two months.
Background and history
Han was indicted on Aug. 29, 2025, on charges including aiding the leader of an insurrection, over his role around Yoon's declaration, the Korea Herald reported.
The Seoul Central District Court first sentenced him to 23 years. The Seoul High Court cut that to 15 years after finding that his failure to act did not itself amount to participation in the insurrection. The High Court found that Han proposed the Cabinet meeting to give the appearance that ministers had deliberated on the decision, and that after the declaration he discussed plans to block access to key institutions and to cut electricity and water to certain media outlets, discussions that involved then-Interior Minister Lee Sang-min, according to the Korea Herald.
Hankyoreh described the prosecution's case as including attempts to make it look as though the Cabinet had deliberated on martial law, and collecting ministers' signatures on documents after martial law had already been declared.
Our analysis
This is a ruling about one defendant's intent, not a reversal of the core finding. The Supreme Court again agreed that the December 2024 declaration was an insurrection and that Han took part in it after it was declared. What changes is how much of his conduct before the declaration counts, which is likely to affect the length of his sentence when the High Court rehears the case.
The story is solidly sourced: it comes from the court's ruling and was reported by AP, the Korea Herald and Hankyoreh. It matters as a marker of how South Korea's courts are handling accountability for the martial law attempt in a key U.S. ally. It carries no direct security risk, and we think a mid-level rank is fair for a political and legal story of this weight; it is not a threat to readers.
What to watch next
No action is needed in the United States.
Signposts: the Seoul High Court's retrial and any new sentence for Han; whether the two-month detention extension is followed by further extensions; and how the Supreme Court's reasoning on intent before the declaration is applied in other martial law cases.
Sources
- apnews.com
- koreaherald.com
- english.hani.co.kr
- Google News: Audacy
- Google News: Audacy
- Google News: WTOP News
- Google News: news.sbs.co.kr
- Google News: SBS 뉴스
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: news.sbs.co.kr
- Google News: SBS 뉴스
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: 아시아경제
- Google News: 아시아경제
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: The Korea Herald
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: The Korea Herald
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: SBS 뉴스
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: SBS 뉴스
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: 동아일보
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: news.sbs.co.kr
- Google News: U.S. News & World Report
- Google News: 경향신문
- Google News: News4JAX
- Google News: ClickOnDetroit | WDIV Local 4
- Google News: WSOC TV
- Google News: 한겨레
- Google News: WV News
- Google News: The Independent
- Google News: Boston 25 News
- Google News: Your Valley
- Google News: The Batesville Daily Guard
- Google News: WV News
- Google News: GazetteXtra
- Google News: The Batesville Daily Guard
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: news.sbs.co.kr
- Google News: SBS 뉴스
- Google News: The New Indian Express
- Google News: The New Indian Express
- Google News: Reuters
- Google News: CBC
- Google News: The Straits Times
- Google News: Kuwait Times
- Google News: South China Morning Post
- Google News: South China Morning Post
- Google News: AP News
- Google News: KIRO 7 News Seattle
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: NST Online
- Google News: The Washington Post
- Google News: StratNews Global
- Google News: Korea JoongAng Daily
- Google News: Chosunbiz
- Google News: Chosunbiz
- Google News: KOCO
- Google News: WDSU
- Google News: WTAE
- Google News: KOAT
- Google News: WBAL-TV
- Google News: The Seattle Times
- Google News: The Japan Times
- Google News: Yonhap News Agency
- Google News: News-Times
- Google News: CNA
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: The Korea Times
- Google News: Jacksonville Journal-Courier
- Google News: rdnewsnow.com
- Google News: the deep dive
- Google News: Al Jazeera
- Google News: Al Jazeera
- Google News: myMotherLode.com
- Google News: Castanet
- Google News: ABC News - Breaking News, Latest News and Videos
- Google News: paNOW
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: 조선일보
- Google News: KSL
- Google News: upi
- Google News: Hankyoreh : English Edition
- News 6 ClickOrlando (Central FL)
- ABC News (US) international
- South China Morning Post
- Japan Times
- Al Jazeera
Confidence and rank
Our confidence is high. Reported by AP, the Korea Herald, SBS and Hankyoreh from the court's ruling.
Our read of the risk to a general reader is low — A court ruling with no direct security impact, though it keeps political tension in South Korea high.
How we rank
Ranks run from 0 to 10 and follow published scoring rules, including how widely a story reaches and how many independent sources report it. A high rank is not the same as a high risk to you. How we score →
More on The Wire